Grandma's NY Pizza: A Slice of New York in Every Bite
Welcome to Grandma’s NY Pizza, where cozy ambiance meets authentic New York-style pizza, crafted with love and family recipes that bring the taste of Brooklyn right to your table.
Best Italian food in Cumming
From Our Oven to Your Heart—NY Pizza Done RightTry our most popular items
Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking
Crispy Fried Ravioli
Golden-brown ravioli stuffed with a savory filling and fried to perfection. Served with a side of tangy marinara sauce for dipping, this classic appetizer is the perfect way to start your meal.
Meat Lover’s Pizza
A carnivore’s dream! Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and ground beef, this pizza is generously topped with melted cheese and served on a perfectly baked crust. A hearty slice for every craving!
Classic Cannoli Delight
End your meal on a sweet note! These crispy pastry shells are filled with a creamy ricotta filling and dusted with powdered sugar for the perfect balance of crunch and sweetness.
Order From Our Website
Skip the wait and enjoy Grandma’s NY Pizza from the comfort of your home! Whether you’re craving our signature pies, crispy appetizers, or decadent desserts, ordering online is quick, easy, and deliciously convenient.
Grandma's NY Pizza: A Slice of Tradition
Discover the rich flavors of authentic New York-style pizza, crafted with love and family tradition. Every bite is a taste of Brooklyn, made with passion and the finest ingredients.
Where Every Slice Feels Like Home
Experience the authentic flavors of New York, right here at Grandma’s NY Pizza! From hand-tossed pizzas loaded with premium toppings to hearty pastas, fresh salads, and indulgent desserts, every bite is crafted with love and tradition. Whether dining in, taking out, or catering for an event, we’re here to serve up deliciousness that feels like home.
Weekly Specials
Unleash your taste buds with Grandma's NY Pizza Weekly Specials! Don't miss out on these limited-time delights. Check out our Weekly Specials and treat yourself to an adventure that's as exciting as the city that never sleeps.
Catering Made Delicious
Bring the taste of New York to your next event with Grandma’s NY Pizza! From cheesy pizzas and hearty pastas to mouthwatering appetizers and desserts, our catering options are crafted to satisfy every crowd. Perfect for parties, meetings, and celebrations—let us handle the food while you enjoy the moment.
What our guests are saying
Check out our most recent reviews!
I passed by here many times and didn't give it a try until now. The pizza was fabulous and the atmosphere was great. Would recommend.
Jonathan C.
A local pizza joint that our hotel recommended. Traditional NY pizza. After a day in the city, their pie hit the spot. Delicious! Costs more than the pizza chains but worth it. Highly recommend. 10/10.
Feisty G.
Stopped in for a quick sub while out on motorcycle. It was on of the best Italian subs I have had in the area. Service was excellent as well. My new go to for an Italian sub.
Ted B.
Featuring
Catering
Dine-In
Take Out
Delivery
Grandmas NY Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up-to-date with us.
Frequently asked questions
We are known for Meat Lovers Pizza, Ravioli, Garlic Bread, Margherita Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Antipasto Salad, Tiramisu, Greek Salad, Meatballs, White Pizza, Salads, Calamari, Cheesecake, Calzones, Supreme Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka, Sicilian Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Bolognese, Gelato, Caesar Salad, Pizza, Stromboli, Caprese, Calzone, Bruschetta, Caprese Salad, Lasagna, Pasta, Garlic Knots, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Pasta Primavera, Spaghetti, Wings, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza
We serve the following areas: Sugar Hill, Big Creek, Cumming, Brookwood, Shake Rag, Suwanee, Pirkle Woods, Buford, Forsyth County, Rest Haven, Johns Creek, Ocee, Drew, Duluth, Coal Mountain, Webb, Alpharetta, Roberts Crossroads, Warsaw, Oscarville.